Imagining you are writing a will or signing a contract but instead of claiming to be yourself, you claim to be your future self from the year 208, awaken through advance technology or time travel. It sounds like a sci-fi idea right, but could it have legal consequences?
Table of Contents
This article dives into the legal side of pretending to be your “future self” in official documents. We explore global laws, important court cases, and expert opinions to see whether it’s just a harmless joke or a real legal issue.
What Does It Mean to Pretend to Be Your Future Self?
Pretending to be your future self when signing something like a contract or will involves you as a persona from a later time—say revived through cryonics or who has time travelled. This could mean using a future date, mentioning things that do not yet exist, or saying you are older than you are. However, this legality depends on why you are doing it, how truthful the document is, and what it’s meant for. Laws around the world focus on keeping legal documents honest and reliable.
Legal Frameworks Governing Identity in Documents
In most legal systems, you are required to be honest about who you are when inking a legal document. Pretending to be your future self even as a joke could lead to problems like fraud or having the document declared invalid. Here are how different approach it:
- United States: Under the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) and state fraud statutes, legal documents like contracts require honesty and good faith. If you claim to be your 2075 self and use that to deceive others could be considered fraud. In United States v. Tipton (2001), the court ruled that using a fake identity in legal documents makes them invalid and could federal law (18 U.S.C. § 1001).
- United Kingdom: The Fraud Act 2006 makes it is illegal to lie about who you are if it causes someone harm. In R v. Ghosh (1982), the UK courts established a two-part test for fraud: the act must be objectively dishonest, and the perpetrator must know it’s dishonest. Pretending to be your future self might be okay if it’s clearly a joke; but, if it misleads someone, it could still be fraud.
- European Union: EU countries like Germany have laws stating people must have legal capacity and act honestly in legal documents. Impersonating your future self could render a document void under § 119 (error as to declaration). A 2017 German court case (BGH ZR 23/16) ruled that using a false identity made a contract invalid.
- Other Countries:
· Australia: The law prohibits misleading conduct in business. A 2019 case (ACCC v. TPG Internet) showed that even creative or unusual misrepresentations can be punished.
· Russia: Russian law requires all agreements to show real intent. If you fake your identity—even as a future self—it could cancel the contract.
Specific Scenarios and Legal Risks
- Wills and Trusts: If you draft a will as your “future self,” a court might question whether you were mentally sound or serious. In the United States, the Estate of Strittmater (1947) demonstrates how mental state can lead to a will being thrown out. Similarly, in the UK, the Wills Act 1837 requires clear intent. If your identity claim is confusing or fake, the will may not hold up.
- Contracts: Signing a contract as your future self could cause a problem if it confuses who you are. In L’Estrange v. Graucob (1934, UK), courts said both sides must clearly understand the contract. A “future self” signature might make the contract unenforceable if it misleads the other person.
- Government Documents: Submitting document as a future self could violate laws against false statements. In the U.S., 26 U.S.C. § 7206 punishes lying on tax documentation with fines or three years in prison. In United States v. Cohen (2015), someone was charged for faking identity on IRS forms—similar issues could arise from future-self claims.
- Cryonics and Revival: If you are cryonically preserved and later revived, claiming to be your “future self” in before documents could complicate legal recognition. A 2021 Yale Law Journal article suggests pre-written documents claiming to be your “future self” may not hold legal weight.
- Intent and Context Matter
Intent and Context Matter
The legality of claiming to be your future self depends on why you’re doing it:
- For Fun or Art: If it’s clearly a joke or creative writing (e.g., “Future Me from 2100” in a casual note), it’s probably harmless, however still not legally binding.
- To Deceive: If you use the future-self idea to trick someone (like to get a loan), it could count as fraud. In the UK, the Fraud Act 2006 allows up to 7 years in prison for false claims.
- Genuine Belief: If you truly believe you are acting as your future self (e.g., due to cryonics), courts may focus on your mental capacity rather than charging you with a crime, as seen in Re W (Mental Capacity) (2000, UK).
Do Any Countries Allow “Future Self” Claims in Legal Documents?
No country has law directly talk about pretending to be your future self in legal documents. But related cases offer clues:
- United States: United States v. Tipton (2001) showed using a fake identity in legal documents could lead to fraud charges. So, posing to be your future self might be illegal if it’s meant to deceive.
- Canada: In R v. Oakes (1986), the court made it clear that false claims that mess with legal processes can be prosecuted, implying that future-self claim affects contracts or official filings, it could be a problem.
- India: The Indian Contract Act says contracts must be based on free and honest agreement. In Raman v. State Bank of India (2020), a contract was thrown out because someone lied about their identity. That means claiming to be a future self could make a contract invalid.
How to Stay Out of Legal Trouble
To avoid legal risks while cliaming to be your future self:
- Be clear about your intent: Label it as a joke, story, or artistic expression if that’s what it is.
- Consult a lawyer: Talking to a lawyer can help you make sure your document is still legally valid.
- Avoid official uses: Don’t use “future self” claims in serious paperwork like tax forms or contracts because accuracy matters there.
Frequently Asked Questions
| Questions | Answers |
| Is it illegal to sign a contract as my future self? | No, it’s not inherently illegal but if it mislead another party or lacks genuine intent, the contract may be void or considered fraud |
| Can I write a will as my future self? | Yes, you can but courts may question your mental capacity or intent. If they find it unclear or strange, the will could be thrown out. |
| What if I’m cryonically preserved and claim to be my revived self? | There’s no legal precedent for this yet. Pretending to be your future revived self in documents written now would likely be seen as speculative and not legally valid. |
| Could this be considered fraud? | Yes, if you pretend to be yourself to trick someone and causes harm could count as fraud under the U.S. law (18 U.S.C. § 1001) or the UK’s Fraud Act 2006. |
| What penalties could I face? | Penalties depend on the country and intent. In the United States, you can be fine up to $100,000 or jailed |
Conclusion
Claiming to be your future self in legal documents might seem to be fun, however it comes with real legal risks. While no country has specific laws against it, it can make documents invalid or lead to fraud charges if used to deceive others.
As technology like cryonics becomes more real, the law may change. However for now, it is safest to use your actual identity in any legal paperwork.
